X

Sign in

Sign in to confirm

Have you forgotten your password?

... or login with Facebook:

Don't have an AndroidPIT account yet? Sign up

Tim Cook: "None Of Their (Android) Tablets Are A Good Experience"

Eric McBride
4

 

During Apple's unveiling of the iPad 3, newly appointed Apple CEO Tim Cook made some pretty harsh comments about Android, and was very quick to use some unproven and some completely FALSE statements to make their newest offering appear to be the only real consumer choice when it came to buying a tablet. While there are a few interesting details about the iPad 3, I personally didn't find it THAT impressive, and it really made me think about if Tim simply has no idea about Android, or if flat out lying about Android is simply something he feels he get away with doing due to the nature and mentality of Apple buying consumers. Let's take a look at a few of his comments, and you be the judge as to whether his comments had any merit, or were complete and utter BS.

 Lets start out with Tims comments on Twitter. Mr Cook showed Twitter running on the iPad and on an Samsung Android tablet, and said the following:

"It kind of looks like a blown-up smartphone app — because that’s exactly what it is. Compare that to Twitter on iPad“.

Let me just start out by saying that this comment is not only sneaky and underhanded, it's just plain stupid and completely lacking of any common sense. As I'm sure both our readers AND Mr Cook is aware of, Twitters appearance on the iPad, or any other app for that matter, has NOTHING to do with if it's on Android or IOS. Rather, it is compeltely up to Twitter and THEIR DEVELOPERS on how they design the Twitter app for Android and IOS. Yes, Android's official Twitter app is not pretty..but that's Twitters fault, NOT Android's. Funny how the Tweetcaster app on my Galaxy Tab 10.1 that's optimized for tablets looks great, and that's all because of the developers who engineered it. Google Maps for IOS is very very limited when compared to its IOS counterpart, but is that the fault of Apple? Certainly not, but rather due to the developers and how they designed it. Tim simply wanted to TRY to make IOS look so much more superior, and unfortunatley, this strategy will work on many iPad buyers that don't think logically about why an app looks like it does. Oh..and by the way Tim...speaking of "blown up apps“, ICS fits almost EVERY app to the screen on my tablet...can you say the same for IOS?

Let's look at his next statement. When talking directly about Android tablets, Mr Cook goes on:

"NONE of their tablets are a great experience“.

WOW. You know what I really like about Google? The fact that they would NEVER say that the iPad delivers a bad experience. Google actually LOVES the iPad and iPhone, as people search Google on the iPad and iPhone. But what Tim says here is at MOST a matter of opinion, but more so a straight up lie. Yes, Android tablets are not selling well right now, and that's for a number of reasons that include price, marketing, and OS version. Lamborghini only sold 1300 cars in 2010...does that make it a BAD car? Certainly not. Maybe that comparison might not make sense to some, as the car is a luxery product that most people can't afford, but the reason I say it is to prove that price matters here, and HIGH END Android tablets simply haven't been priced competitively enough or marketed aggressively enough to take off yet. That is quickly changing, and to say that all of them don't deliver a great experience is not only false, it's just silly. I love my Galaxy Tab 10.1, and even iPad owners are impressed by it. Asus, Sony, and many more have also delivered some great tablet's, so let's just stop with the "the ONLY good experience is with us“ talk shall we? Hardware wise MANY Android tablets are superior to the iPad in so many ways, and the OS is so much more intereactive, fun, and gives users more options and choices. That being said, I would NEVER say the iPad delivers a bad experience, cause it doesn't . It's simply a DIFFERENT experience. Common Tim..really.

Let's have another look at what Tim had to say, this time about the Nvidia processors that power Android tablets:

"Apple's A5X DUAL CORE processor delivers up to 4 times more power than the Tegra 3“

Ok Tim...what I will admit here, is that this statement is at least one that later can be PROVEN to be BS or truth, and as soon as we get our hands on an iPad 3, we will benchmark it against the Transformer Prime's Tegra 3 powered chipset to see these results. It could be that you're wrong, and it could be that you speak the truth, but at least you saying something that everyone will have a chance to confirm, and not just talking about how great your products are. Nvidia was quick to call Apple out on this, as Nvidia rep Ken Brown said that Apple failed to backup their claims with any benchmark proof as reported by Phandroid:

"We have to understand what the application was that was used. Was it one or a variety of applications? What drivers were used? There are so many issues to get into with benchmark."

So until the device hits the shelves and can be tested, I'll leave that one alone. It's really strange to me as well how Tim takes really direct stabs at Samsung, considering that you'll probably be pretty suprised that when you open up an iPhone or iPad WHOS parts you'll find laying in there (not all, but many). Also..."quad core graphics“? Nice way to cover up the fact that your processor is still a dual core and not a quad core chipset. Clever....And lastly, if Android doesn't concern you so much, why do you keep mentioning it and its partners at YOUR press conferences?

Oh well...in the end, it's about the iPad 3 and selling it to the masses, and since these dirty/untrue little statements seem to work for many Apple consumers, I guess you can't blame him. And no..I don't dislike Tim Cook..I actually kind of respect him for being one of the first who seems ready to sit and negotiate with Google rather than continue throw up lawsuits left and right. I have nothing at all against the iPad, but I sure will call anyone out on it when they make untrue comparisons. But the fact is this: When it comes to Android tablets, there's no denying that they are getting better and better by the day, and with Windows 8 and ICS/Jellybean tablets on the horizon, lets see how Tim is talking next year when the iPad 4 is released.

Picture credits: FastCompany.com

Related Topics

Related Articles

News / Hardware
8 2 days ago

How to replace your Android boot animation in recovery

News / Hardware
4 10 hours ago

Nexus 6 ''confirmed'' as being built by Motorola

News / Hardware
2 16 hours ago

Google Nexus 6 reportedly a 5.9 inch phablet developed by Motorola

Comments

Write new comment:
  • Jay chew Mar 8, 2012 Link

    Commenting on...
    1. Indeed its Twitter's fault for the ugly look on Android. But still it's an advantage for iPad which is worth to mention. Android lacking of quality control is the main reason all these ugly apps floating in its market.
    2. Android has been tweaked by too many manufacturers. I believe a lot of us has been grunting over new updates. Some being left out from updates. Serious bug and lag. UNLESS the device is rooted. But, how many of us actually know how to root? So, a good experience? Not everyone.
    3. A5 chip is already proven 2 times faster than Tegra 3 right? So by just comparing the A5X and A5, which primary school kids don't know how to do the math?

    0
    0
  • Eric McBride Mar 9, 2012 Link

    Hi Jay, and thanks for your comments!

    1. Yes, its Twitters fault, but I cant agree that its a real "advantage". I mean ok, Google maps on Android is an "advantage" because of the extra functionality thats specific to Android..but Twitters app looking like that on Android is only due to the Twitter devs being too lazy/interested/ to tweak the UI. There are lots of apps that look better on android and vice versa, so in the end, I dont see how either side could say thats a real unique selling point.
    2 Oh yeah..this I totally agree with. Skins have KILLED Androids chances of effectively managing updates in a timely manner. That being said, newer devices like the Galaxy S2 and Galaxy Nexus run great WITHOUT being rooted, and its the same with the Prime and Galaxy Tab 10.1 ect. To say ALL dont give a great experience is simply false.
    3. "Faster" in what? Could you give a bit more details on HOW its twice as fast as Tegra 3? Does it prove a better gaming experience, higher framerate, ect? Remember, Android and IOS utilize memory in 2 COMPLETELY different ways, so that has to be taken into consideration when running benchmarks. I think both Tegra 3 and the A5X are already fast enough..its a MEMORY upgrade that I would personally like to see in tablets! Gimme 2 gigs of RAM and I ll be happy!!! :-D

    0
    0
  • Jay chew Mar 10, 2012 Link

    I guess you're right. Good question over there. "Does it prove a better gaming experience, higher framerate, ect?" We'll only know the answer till we got hands on on the new the iPad.
    Still, I believe that Apple's end to end control will provide a better experience. But limitation is what user's will be facing. Android will be better if they have stricter quality control.

    0
    0
  • Eric McBride Mar 13, 2012 Link

    I agree man..that end to end control is what Google could also have if they would use the Motorola purchase to their advantage. That quality control your talking about is EXACTLY what Apple HAS and what Android very badly needs!

    0
    0