Sign in

Sign in to confirm

Have you forgotten your password?

... or login with Facebook:

Don't have an AndroidPIT account yet? Sign up

Are large smartphones killing small tablets?

Scott Adam Gordon
17

First we wanted them smaller. Then we wanted them bigger. Now, we don’t know what we want. Manufacturers can design mobile technology to virtually any size, so the focus is less on “bigger is better” and more on targeting the right products at the right consumers.

teaser smartphone tablet
The Sony Xperia Z Ultra screen is only marginally smaller than that of the Google Nexus 7. © ANDROIDPIT

Making smartphones with a screen size of around five inches makes sense, doesn’t it? They are portable, but still provide a large enough screen to comfortably show pictures of angry cats to your mates at the pub. I can also see the appeal of the 10-inch tablet, for those who want a bit more functionality and horsepower without taking the step up to laptop size and price.

In the middle are the phablets, and things get a bit hazy here. Neither big enough for one task nor small enough for the other. However, fantastic devices are no doubt being produced in this range, and if ‘the people’ want it, who am I to judge? With that being said, I can foresee challenges up the road for the future of tablets, particular the smaller kind.

com teaser 4devices
© ANDROIDPIT

5-inch smartphones with attractive screen-to-body-ratios, loaded with power and dense ppi, these devices are offering much of the same functionality as small tablets, and they are pocket friendly. Just like tablets were able to muscle in on the laptop market with convenient, low-priced devices that provide a very similar experience, large smartphones are primed to claim business from the small tablet demographic.

The biggest reason for this, naturally, is size. You can’t take an 8-inch tablet everywhere you go, not without some discomfort in your nether regions (behave, please). People keep their smartphones with them at all times, and become anxious when they are without them. Phones need to be carried with you, tablets, like laptops, are a luxury carriable - they’re not for the bar or the fair or the whiskey tour. So why would someone who has a 5.5-inch smartphone want a small tablet?

LG G3 HTC One M8 display
Aren't the HTC One (M8) (left) and the LG G3 (right) screens big enough? © AndroidPIT

Let’s look at a wider question first: Why buy a tablet at all? Well, for starters movies and pictures look better on them. Productivity apps also become easier to use, typing and emailing and organising is better on a bigger screen with a bigger keyboard. It has application for business, and they work better as e-readers. But smartphone technology is becoming increasingly sophisticated, watching videos on the likes of the LG G3 compared to a Google Nexus 7 (2013) just isn’t all that different. And when you go one step further, comparing the likes of the Sony Xperia Z Ultra to the Nexus 7, well, one of them is unnecessary, right?

I really want to rustle some feathers here and say small tablets are terrible. Pointless. But I can’t say that, because this area has brought about some great devices. The Nexus 7 is actually a spiffing device. As is the Samsung Galaxy Tab Pro 8.4. But here is where I see a problem. If a person has a HTC One (M8), it's true they may still find use for a 10-inch tablet. I’ve been playing with the Samsung Galaxy Tab S 10.5 in the office, and there are definitely areas where a five-inch screen just isn't big enough (drawing in SketchBook Express being one of them, despite there being a version for sub 7-inch devices). The added horsepower of a tablet can also handle certain games better than smaller devices.

androidpit sketchbook express
Samsung Galaxy Tab S: I’m clearly no artist, but this would look even worse on a smartphone. © ANDROIDPIT

But would you consider owning both an 8-inch tablet and a 10-inch tablet? Probably not. And are people really in a hurry to substitute their smartphone for a small tablet that they can’t carry around for normal day-to-day use? I don't think so. What it’s going to come down to is portability. With the Nexus 7 considered non-pocketable, there is no reason you wouldn’t go bigger tablet or slightly smaller screened phone. Especially while the apps and interface are both very similar.

I’m a lover of all devices, big and small, but with large smartphones becoming powerful enough for most tasks, I’m finding it hard to see value in any larger device without a physical keyboard. So now I’m asking you, are small tablets going to survive the test of time? If you own one, let me know in the comments below what your experiences are. Anybody else, I'm looking forward to some discussion on this because I know not everyone is going to agree with me!

Related Topics

From the forum. Join the discussion now!

Comments

Write new comment:
  • Kimiko Yu 3 months ago Link

    I want an all in one. tablets are useless. there need to be more phones the size of the z ultra.

    0
    • User picture
      Admin
      Scott Adam Gordon 3 months ago Link

      This is interesting. Why do you need a device which is the size of the Z Ultra? What can't you do with a 5 inch smartphone that you can with the Z Ultra?

      0
  • Byron Garay 3 months ago Link

    I use my Note 3 as both phone and tablet productivity in daily basis...And iPad for other tasks where i really need a bigger screen.

    0
    • User picture
      Admin
      Scott Adam Gordon 3 months ago Link

      I think the Note 3 is an excellent device and I can imagine people use it for lots of tasks. What size is the iPad screen?

      0
  • Nathan Pallas 3 months ago Link

    I have both a Galaxy Note and a Nexus 7. I'd say I use them 20% phone and 80% tablet on a daily basis. I rarely use the S Pen features of the Note anymore, the main reasons I got the phone.

    For me a tablet will always be a necessity.

    0
    • User picture
      Admin
      Scott Adam Gordon 3 months ago Link

      So what do you use the Nexus 7 for? Or what can you do on the Nexus 7 that you can't on the Note? :)

      0
      • Nathan Pallas 2 months ago Link

        Things I do with both devices are pretty much even, although I find photo editing is so much easier with that slightly larger screen.

        The Note keeps up well, but the Nexus 7 just...feels better! To be honest I would probably go down to about 4.5 inches for my next handset. I've discovered I don't need a screen so big whilst out and about.

        0
  • Gwen Miller 3 months ago Link

    Hi there,

    I have got a Samsung Galaxy S5 and a Samsung Galaxy tab 3.8 0. Both are constantly in use. The smartphone being at my side all day whilst I use the tablet for writing, e-mailing, and some professional software. Also I play games on both, quick games like Candy Crush Saga on the phone, more sophisticated games on the tablet. I am quite happy with the solution, I certainly wouldn't want to carry a phablet around.

    1
    • User picture
      Admin
      Scott Adam Gordon 3 months ago Link

      Yeah I carried the Sony Xperia Z Ultra around with me while I was writing this and I definitely wouldn't want to do that again. Maybe it's different if you carry a bag with you everywhere you go. I just wouldn't want to hold something that size up to my ear in public!

      1
      • Nathan Pallas 2 months ago Link

        That was a ridiculous phablet. Stunning to look at but totally unpractical.

        0
  • Karen Mulhern 3 months ago Link

    As we become increasingly nomadic (and I see more and more of this 3mos here, 6mos there, who-knows-where-next happening every year) I think we'll all prefer single pocket devices on which we'll do everything.
    Tablets are the PDAs of the mid 2000s, a transitional, short term technology at best!

    0
    • User picture
      Admin
      Scott Adam Gordon 3 months ago Link

      Wow so you think ALL tablets will eventually die out, regardless of size?? I'm not so sure, Android tablets, and especially Apple ones, have quite a following now... PDAs never really caught on :/

      0
  • Bojan M. 3 months ago Link

    I think that all tablets are practically useless. Like I read somewhere, tablets are appendices (med.) of mobile world, or something like that. Phablets are excellent devices, you want any bigger than that, there are plenty of notebooks and ultrabooks.

    1
    • User picture
      Admin
      Scott Adam Gordon 3 months ago Link

      Yeah if I was going to use anything bigger than a smartphone I'd want to be using a mouse/keyboard

      0
  • rich brown 3 months ago Link

    I had a Note 3 and 7 inch Kindle Fire HDX. I did find that this was a redundant setup, however I also found that the Note was too big for me to carry comfortably in my pocket, and the tablet was too small to enjoy magazines on. So I now use a Nexus 5 and the 8.9 inch version of the Kindle Fire HDX...and all is right with the world.

    1
    • User picture
      Admin
      Scott Adam Gordon 3 months ago Link

      Haha yeah that seems like a good balance, I wouldn't mind that setup myself!

      0