X

Sign in

Sign in to confirm

Have you forgotten your password?

... or login with Facebook:

Don't have an AndroidPIT account yet? Sign up

Privacy, schmivacy. Cell phone carriers givin' it up to advertisers.

Kris Carlon
6

The four major cell phone networks in the USA are looking to sell your user specs to advertisers, Tech Crunch reports. That is, the ones who don't already. AT&T now wants to take your browsing history, location data, and online habits and get on the bandwagon pioneered by Facebook and Google. Verizon, Sprint and T-Mobile are apparently already in on the current fashion for making even more money off the people that already pay for their services.

phones
Do you want to pay to have your own information sold back to you? / © Facebook

Now, I'm all for making money out of my online footprint, web searches and social media activity. Hang on, let me rephrase that, I'm all for ME making money out of my online footprint. If everyone wants to cut me a cheque from a percentage of what my user data adds up to in advertising revenue then I'd be totally OK with that.

Of course, we're talking such tiny amounts per data-generator that you'd never get much more than a free cup of coffee out of it, but when you add up all the companies doing it, you might be drinking free coffee for the rest of your life.

And at the very least, if we were to become shareholders in our own online 'product,' then the cost to those doing the selling would be massive, which might make them a little less eager to sell off our valuable online mojo. They always seem to palm it off as 'personalizing' our web experience, but should the trade in our consumer data be something we simply have to accept?

smartphone preise sinken
If service providers had to pay users, would they stop selling our information?/ © Hersteller/AndroidPIT

Of course, leaving an online footprint is part and parcel of using search engines, social media and apps, and it certainly can make your time spent online more relevant, but if the only benefit is simply to try to sell me more crap then I for one can certainly live without it. Having said that though, I tend to ignore ads anyway, so what's the difference if I'm ignoring ads that are supposedly more directed to my interests?

I'm well aware that ads pay for sites and it makes sense that those ads are tailored to the audience using the web page, app or whatever. So using customer data in an aggregate, anonymous way (that means your activity provides statistics that don't point back to you personally) makes sound business sense. So what are we all worked up about?

As AT&T's new privacy policy states: ''To be clear, you will still receive the same number of ads, they just won’t be as relevant.'' Fair call. And to be even clearer: ''We don’t sell your personal information, and we won’t use it unless you tell us you want us to do that.'' Thanks for clarifying AT&T. But what this increasingly means is companies won't sell it or use it unless we specifically tell them not to.

Privacy
Sure, this seems reasonable. / © funxite.com

So it's not MY information they're selling, just everyone's. And I get to be a part of that everyone. If I choose to. To better enhance my consumer, I mean, web experience. They also note that everyone else is selling this information, so why shouldn't they. We're all familiar with Facebook and Google ads, so why not get used to it on a service you pay for too?

Fortunately, opting out of this stuff is not so difficult, and the simple fact that everyone is doing it is slowly making us all more aware of how our information is used and how we can protect our privacy if that's our thing. The trusty folk at Tech Crunch have compiled the opt out links for the four major carriers.

Some say it's all no big deal, that we're givin' it away anyway so who cares what's done with it. Fair enough, but there are others out there who think that this is the thin end of the wedge and that before long, we'll be paying companies to make money off us (oh wait, we already do that).

People used to think putting information online was harmless, then we had a multi-billion dollar identity theft market that barely existed before. Fortunately, as problems increased, awareness did too and identity theft is nowhere near the bogeyman it once was. Then again, we had Facebook scraping up user phone numbers without their permission just last week.

The recent PRISM-scandal, and news of Brazil, France and China doing the same thing, makes everyone feel uncomfortable, and for good reason. No-one wants their private information read through by the government, but everything is OK if it's advertisers doing it to make more money?

privacy
So what is an apprpriate level of user information to share? / © http://www.digitaltrends.com/

After all, what is the real difference between social media companies, search engines, phone companies and so on giving compiled information on users to the government, and those very same service providers selling that information to advertisers? It all feels wrong to me. At the very least the government has national security to fall back on, whereas advertisers are simply out to make a buck.

Of course, we all feel that we've got nothing to hide, but that doesn't mean we should be giving it all away for free. And it certainly doesn't feel to me like we should be giving it away for free so others can make money off it and then sell it all back to us.

Do you meticulously manage and monitor what information you share online? Do you like the idea of more relevant content being delivered to you by advertisers or does it all make you feel a little icky?

Related Topics

From the forum. Join the discussion now!

Related Articles

Magazine / Hardware
0 12 hours ago

Win a Google Cardboard virtual reality toolkit!

Magazine / Hardware
0 2 hours ago

Android accessibility settings: 5 hidden options everyone should be using

Magazine / Hardware
0 8 hours ago

How to open SIM card slot if you don't have a SIM tool

Comments

Write new comment:
  • Glostermeteor Jul 8, 2013 Link

    I dont even trust opt outs. The only sure fire why of stopping the carriers and governments snooping on your data is by encrypting your connection. Thankfully there are some free and easy to use VPN tools on the Play store that will totally encrypt your data connections and route your data stream to other parts of the world. I use Hotspot Shield VPN, its very easy to use and means that all my carrier sees is an encrypted stream of data they have no idea what that data is. I do find it quite ironic that these kinds of tools were developed originally for pro-democracy campaigners in Iran and China, and now we having to use the same tools here in the West to combat snooping.

    0
    0
  • mithun s Jul 8, 2013 Link

    Thanks glostermeteor for pointing towards VPN tools

    0
    0
  • Glostermeteor Jul 8, 2013 Link

    No problem. These tools really work too. I was very recently in a part of the Middle East where all Voice Over IP Services (such as Skype or Vonage) are banned and blocked by the government there. As soon as you switch on one of these tools all the data from those apps are then encrypted and therefore bypassing any block.

    0
    0
  • User picture
    Admin
    Kris Carlon Jul 9, 2013 Link

    Thanks for the tip Glostermeteor. It's a shame we now feel like we can't trust anyone, even our own governments and service providers. Have you joined the forum discussion yet?

    0
    0
  • Jeremy Gray 10 months ago Link

    Hotspot Sheild vpn

    0
    0
  • User picture
    Admin
    Kris Carlon 10 months ago Link

    I installed HotSpot Shield VPN ages ago and it never worked for me so I uninstalled it. Glad it works for you though!

    0
    0