Sign in

Sign in to confirm

Have you forgotten your password?

... or login with Facebook:

Don't have an AndroidPIT account yet? Sign up

Poll: Do we really need waterproof phones?

Kris Carlon
9

Sony has just teased devices that can withstand two meters of continual submersion in the lead up to IFA 2014. Sony's Xperia Z range has always been dustproof and water-tight for up to 30 minutes in one meter of fresh water, and we've seen more phones following suit this year. But seriously, just how waterproof do we need our phones?

Xperia Z1s
Waterproofness is great, but is it worth paying extra for? © Sony

Making a smartphone dustproof makes sense. Especially if you tend to live somewhere where there are dust storms or you drive on dirt roads a lot. But even if you don't, dust is an everyday part of life, and if dust gets into your phone and breaks it then you have a serious problem. There's not much you can about the slow ingress of dirt particles. But other than protecting against a bit of a rain shower, how essential is waterproofing to a phone? 

Sony Waterproof Ad
Is this just getting ridiculous? Or should all phones be fully waterpoof? © Sony

Having a waterproof smartphone sounds lovely, but what do you actually use it for? Other than being a bit less stressed at a party when you're standing by the edge of a pool I can't really see many other benefits. Sure, you can play games in the shower, put your phone through the washing machine or make calls in the surf, but is this worth paying extra for and having ungainly flaps over every port? Or is it just an over-engineered solution for occasional drops into the sink? You tell me.

Now, I must point out that most IP-rated devices are not protected against chlorine, salt water or dishwashing liquid. Touchscreens also do not work underwater (this is why Sony has a dedicated camera shutter button). The examples I've used in this text were specifically selected to be obvious, but non-supported, examples of the real-life failings of waterproofing. So I ask again, just how waterproof do we need our phones to be?

Do we really need phones to be waterproof?

Related Topics

From the forum. Join the discussion now!

Comments

Write new comment:
  • Timothy Cremeans 3 months ago Link

    Yes, I do agree that we really need these smartphones because it helps not worry about water getting in our phones as well as we like taking pictures underwater as we want to capture a different kind of beauty.

    0
  • Amat Mulisha 3 months ago Link

    I dont know but for me, its important to someone that works near water or for bikers also. smartphone with this function a little bit expensive than the other version

    0
  • flooney 3 months ago Link

    I do not go swimming with my smartphone. So it's completely useless to me. But if anybody thinks it's necessary to him, then get your xperia z xy series and go swimming :-)

    0
  • User picture
    Admin
    Kris Carlon 3 months ago Link

    I can appreciate that cyclists in the UK, Pacific North-West or other rainy areas probably have a different level of ''necessity'' for waterproofing than others. I think if it can be rolled into the ''normal'' price of a phone then sure, why not have it, but I certainly don't want to pay extra for it.

    0
  • User picture
    Yanwyn 3 months ago Link

    Do we need waterproof phones? Yes, why not?! You pay a lot of money for these devices, so moisture resistant at least can only be a good thing. Which is why my last two devices have been Motorola's.

    0
  • Bob visser 3 months ago Link

    I would love to have a waterproof phone. Every year when I go on holiday with my motorcycle I keep my phone in a plastic bag while I am driving. And sometimes when I am driving my bicycle I worry about my phone when it rains

    0
  • Kenn Sanchez 3 months ago Link

    right now I have a water resistant phone which is my moto G on my boost mobile carrier. I have never had a water resistant phone yet a waterproof phone. I think they would be handy just in case you may find yourself around water and you oops dropped your phone. I think it will be just more for convenience them for anything else. Just saying.

    0
  • Bojan M. 3 months ago Link

    Well, who wouldn't want something like that? It's not an absolutely necessary feature, but it's a welcomed one. I have a waterproof phone, and while I haven't had the situation that would make use of such feature yet, I'm feeling much relieved because I don't have to worry about getting the phone wet anymore. Warranty does not apply when your phone is wet. Moisture is a phone killer (as it stands for any electronics). So, I ask again, do we really think making our phones waterproof is unnecessary?

    About some of the points mentioned...

    As it stands now, only some premium phones are waterproof. They are not expensive because they are made waterproof, but because they are premium devices. It's not like they cost you your kidney just because of this.

    Not every port needs to be covered with flaps. And some people are ok with flaps. I, for example, don't like holes all around my phone and prefer clean and closed design.

    The situations mentioned here, in which waterproofing supposedly doesn't work, are actually a bad argument. It's not that waterproofing doesn't work in those situations, but the phones in question were not designed specifically for them (but for clean water) and certifications are meant only for regular water. But, I can tell you for a fact that even in those situations your waterproof phone will be waterproof, even for a prolonged time. The phone must be cleaned afterwards because some of the chemicals (salt, chlorine, detergent) may be corrosive for the rubber (or other materials) responsible for waterproofing your phone.

    The point is, if your phone is waterproof and you drop it in any water based liquid, it will survive, fully functional at that, even if it spends some time there. But, if it's not waterproof and you drop it there, you may try to save it with some rice or something, but the probability is much higher that you will not (even if it powers up again, not all functions may work or it may be dead at any moment later; also, no warranty anymore).

    0
  • Francois Chamberland 3 months ago Link

    And the answer is a very loud NO.

    0