Register now » Login
« Login

Forgotten your password?

OsmAnd

Sep

9

Apple Wins In Germany- No Galaxy 10.1 In Europe's Heart *UPDATE*

by Aaron Tilton on Sep 9, 2011 11:47:42 AM — read 2,721 times

Blow for Samsung and Android: The decision has fallen in Duesseldorf. Apple has succeeded in getting a ban on the Galaxy tab 10.1 in Germany. What more can you say? Based on their disappointed response at the IFA, German Android fans are going to take this hard.

At the moment it isn't clear if the stop will be expanded to other Galaxy devices but based on the wave of lawsuits around the world, we wouldn't be surprised if Apple tries to expand on their success at the expense of the Android community. When the official press release is out, will bring it to you ASAP


UPDATE:

Apple's main arguement hinged on the fact that the Samsung Galaxy Tablet was similar in appearnce to the Apple Ipad. According to the main Judge, Samsung failed to keep "the required distance from the established Apple design", which is why he has issued an ban on the sale of all Galaxy Tabs 10.1 in Germany. In 2004 Apple copyrighted the so called "Taste profile" of the tablet PC in general meaing that all companeis producing products with similar appearances could be in violation of their "Taste Profile" copy right.

According to Germany'S Der Spiegel the ban could move beyond German boarders to the whole of Europe.

 

UPDATE 2:

A link to the full press release can be found here.

Comments

Sep 9, 2011 11:57:06 AM

I'm confused. Can you tell me more? On what charges did they succeed? Wasn't the evidence tampered with? Didn't the judge throw the case out before? This is bad reporting, need more info.

Sep 9, 2011 11:59:40 AM

This can't be right... I mean really... what are they smoking?

Sep 9, 2011 12:01:58 PM

We don't haev any more details at the moment. We're still waiting for official word from both the court and the companies in question. We will however bring all the latest as soon as it breaks.

Sep 9, 2011 12:11:34 PM

Samsung should have seen this coming shouldn't they? If there sticking so many million in development couldn't they have done their own research and figured out how to avoid Apples patents?

Sep 9, 2011 2:20:16 PM

The Samsung Galaxy Tablet looks to much like an iPad.

That the Designes (Google translate translates “Geschmacksmuster” to “designs”) where vague did not matter any more in the final verdict. The (female) judge had the real devices available.

She also pointed out that Acer, ASUS and Toshiba where able to create tables pc which do not resemble the iPad as closely.

So my guess: If Samsung would paint the devices brown like ASUS there would not be a Problem.

Sep 9, 2011 2:42:14 PM

Why does it matter that the judge was female?

Sep 9, 2011 3:00:12 PM

Well that's obvious isn't..... she displayed sound judgement and reason! But seriously this decision is crap. Though if they already knew that Apple had a design copyright shouldn't they have been able to account for that during planing like Martin suggested?

Sep 9, 2011 3:05:42 PM

So what are they going to do with units that are already in the country? Because Id take those off their hands for cheep.

Sep 9, 2011 4:19:42 PM

It is an import ban for Samsung only. Devices already in the country can be sold. And if you really want one I suggests a weekend trip to Switzerland.

Sep 9, 2011 5:32:31 PM

@Martin Really? Is there a huge price hike? I heard that the taxes in der Schweitz are a bit higher then in Germany.... think it would be worth the trip down for Android Fans if they really want to get their hands on one?

Sep 9, 2011 5:53:07 PM

No , sales tax is lower (8%) but salaries are higher and companies allow them-self a higher profit margin.

Here some example prices:

16BG: http://www.netchange-shop.ch/tabid/6428/Default.aspx?ID=177596

32GB: http://www.netchange-shop.ch/tabid/6428/Default.aspx?ID=179370

And if it is worth it depends how far north one lives.

Sep 9, 2011 6:06:02 PM

Cool thanks for the info!

Write new comment:

You must log in or register now,
to submit a comment!

As a logged in user, you can also change the order of the comments.

 
Ad

Bookmark / E-Mail

Click on an icon to bookmark this article.
» Send this article via e-mail

Tags / Topics

Archive

Android Forum

General
Android
Google Android Phones
HTC Android Phones
Huawei Android Phones
LG Android Phones
Motorola Android Phones
Samsung Android Phones
Sony Ericsson Android Phones
Other Android Devices
Android Tablets
Other Android Tablets
Android OS Forums
Android Developer Forum
Miscellaneous

Support AndroidPIT

Do you enjoy AndroidPIT? We?re thrilled to have your support! How does it work? Just click on the links below.

Recommend to Others

Enjoy AndroidPIT? Then please let other people know about us!

Questions / Help

Do you have questions about AndroidPIT or simply want to learn more about us? Then you might find the following links helpful.

  You are reading: Apple Wins In Germany- No Galaxy 10.1 In Europe's Heart *UPDATE* - AndroidPIT. All times are UTC+02:00. The time now is 7:17 PM.