Hello people,
I'm not an expert in this matter but the main issue now that Samsung is facing is that it's being accused of patent infringements for selling phones having an Android OS. The situation I want to describe is as follows:
Samsung or any other android phone manufacturer sells their phones without the main OS, but a BIOS-like booter.
This BIOS would then allow customers to install the OS of their choice (In this case Android). (Just like a normal PC)
That would definitely solve the problem of users bricking their phones, but my questions are:
1. Will this help manufacturers evade patent infringement accusations ?
2. Is it feasible ?
Looking forward for your comments
You are here: Android Forum » Android » Android Visions » Possible solution for the patent war ... ?
Go to: Recent posts | Own threads | Watched threads
Go to: Recent posts | Own threads | Watched threads
Possible solution for the patent war ... ?
You must be registered at AndroidPIT in order to participate in the Android Forum.
Alain Haddad  Rank: Android Junior Posts: 5 Join date: Feb 3, 2012 |
Possible solution for the patent war ... ? created on Feb 3, 2012 7:15:52 AM |
Eric McBride 
Status: Super Blogger, Super Tester, Moderator Rank: Android Gold Senior Posts: 1,297 Join date: Jan 3, 2012 |
RE: Possible solution for the patent war ... ? created on Feb 3, 2012 1:05:20 PM — modified on Feb 3, 2012 1:06:09 PM
Hmm...you make a good point, but I think if it were that simple Samsung and Google would have already considered it as an option.
Also, in the end even if users had a choice of which OS to install (which would already be insanely tedious to implement in a consumer friendly fashion), the OS would still remain on the phone, meaning that the end result would be the same. Also, having to install the OS themselves on the phone would seem like too much for a lot of consumers, and would most likely push many of them directly to the iPhone. |
|
Alain Haddad Rank: Android Junior Posts: 5 Join date: Feb 3, 2012 |
RE: Possible solution for the patent war ... ? created on Feb 3, 2012 2:17:05 PM
Thank you for you comment
Eric McBride Also, in the end even if users had a choice of which OS to install (which would already be insanely tedious to implement in a consumer friendly fashion), the OS would still remain on the phone, meaning that the end result would be the same. Eric McBride Also, having to install the OS themselves on the phone would seem like too much for a lot of consumers, and would most likely push many of them directly to the iPhone. |
Eric McBride
Status: Super Blogger, Super Tester, Moderator Rank: Android Gold Senior Posts: 1,297 Join date: Jan 3, 2012 |
RE: Possible solution for the patent war ... ? created on Feb 3, 2012 5:30:47 PM
Ah ok..you mean having the choice of which custom Android ROM to install? I thought you meant that you would basically boot up the phone, and you would have a choice between booting android, windows mobile, or another OS. Got ya. But if you mean custom ROMS, that could be a really big headache, as Google would have to check that all the custom ROMS you could boot up would legally comply to Androids standards.
And your right, for people like you and me, that choice would be exciting...but Apple has proven that the average consumer wants something that they can turn on, and BAM..it just works. I really like your ideas, but I think it would be hard to capture the mass market with such a concept, as its more targeted for people like you and me who like being able to customize, root, and modify our phones operating system. |
|
Alain Haddad Rank: Android Junior Posts: 5 Join date: Feb 3, 2012 |
RE: Possible solution for the patent war ... ? created on Feb 3, 2012 6:11:27 PM
What do you mean by "legally comply to Androids standards" ?
|
|
Eric McBride
Status: Super Blogger, Super Tester, Moderator Rank: Android Gold Senior Posts: 1,297 Join date: Jan 3, 2012 |
RE: Possible solution for the patent war ... ? created on Feb 6, 2012 12:56:19 PM — modified on Feb 6, 2012 12:57:13 PM Alain Haddad What do you mean by "legally comply to Androids standards" ? It means that even though Android is open source, you cant do EVERYTHING with it that you want. Maybe you have heard of Cyanogen, probably the most famous Android modder. Check out what Google wrote to him due to the way he built a customized ROM and you ll see what I mean: http://gizmodo.com/5367420/google-threatens-cyanogen-android-hacker-with-cease+and+desist Remember..while Androids source code is open source...specific google products like gmail and youtube,ect are NOT. Those applications are Googles intellectual property, meaning that Google controls how they are distributed. |
|
Alain Haddad Rank: Android Junior Posts: 5 Join date: Feb 3, 2012 |
RE: Possible solution for the patent war ... ? created on Feb 7, 2012 4:19:07 PM
mm, yes I've heard of the guy but never knew Google wrote him to stop...
I'm thinking of another approach now. How about extremely decentralized production. In this case, main manufacturers like Samsung would not sell the entire device but only sell parts such as processors, screens, etc... to numerous manufacturers. There's no way you can take on 10000 manufacturing companies... This will also help boost third world countries' economies by promoting localized assembly and production... |
|
Eric McBride
Status: Super Blogger, Super Tester, Moderator Rank: Android Gold Senior Posts: 1,297 Join date: Jan 3, 2012 |
RE: Possible solution for the patent war ... ? created on Feb 8, 2012 12:55:10 PM
Well, in all honesty, Google has more than enough power and influence to take on 10000 companies.
 But the issue is, I personally wouldnt like to see 10000 companies actually making the phones. How many of those 10000 would produce high quality devices, and how many would produce bad ones that could in the long term damage Androids reputation?Also, in terms of the software, how could Google release updates for so many manufacturers? Its already difficult enough doing it for just Samsung, HTC, Motorola, LG, and Sony! The method that you mention, while extremely interesting and creative, would take fragmentation (which is already a problem within the Android ecosystem) to an entirely new level. |
|
Alain Haddad Rank: Android Junior Posts: 5 Join date: Feb 3, 2012 |
RE: Possible solution for the patent war ... ? created on Feb 9, 2012 8:16:45 AM
What I'm suggesting is not for near future...
Fragmentation is an issue but it's currently being worked upon. Provided the solution is a scalable one, then we would expect that any new version of Android will be installable on all devices right away. And this is without the intervention of Google to tweak it just right for each device. ...of course provided the system has the requirements. If this is done right, it will help develop the mindset that differentiates between hardware and software which, in turn, provides more immunity to the presence of bad hardware. Take a look at what Microsoft is doing in the computer industry. Hardware manufacturers are numerous. Windows is able to run on just about any of the hardware sets. Yes there are people using Macs,but the way I see it Windows-based systems are more numerous. I also want to add that it shouldn't be up to Google to insure that newest version of Android runs on all devices. It should leverage the efforts of the hardware manufactures to provide the right drivers. This way, the newest version will be released to existing devices with a small fraction of the current time. To further reduce this time, Google should put forward some standards for the drivers that the manufacturers can follow. |
|
Eric McBride
Status: Super Blogger, Super Tester, Moderator Rank: Android Gold Senior Posts: 1,297 Join date: Jan 3, 2012 |
RE: Possible solution for the patent war ... ? created on Feb 9, 2012 12:29:13 PM — modified on Feb 9, 2012 12:29:22 PM
Hmm...its really an interesting concept, and yes, it shouldnt be solely Google's responsibility to make sure Android runs properly on each device. The microsoft example is a good one, but the difference is that Microsofts OS is not open source, so theres no modifying it. If 10,000 different companies are all making Android phones, they would all simply need to comply to Googles licensing standards. In theory it could work. It would be a hell of a job to implement though.
|
You are here: Android Forum » Android » Android Visions » Possible solution for the patent war ... ?
Go to: Recent posts | Own threads | Watched threads
Go to: Recent posts | Own threads | Watched threads