X

Sign in

Forgotten your password?

... or login with Facebook:

Don't have an AndroidPIT account yet? Sign up

Carcassonne – A Blast from the Past?

on 9/19/11 9:00 AM

Tested version: 2
Latest version: 7
Requires Android: from 1.6

Add this app to my favorites

Summary

Carcassonne is set in the Middle Ages and you play the role of some sort of blue blooded tyrant who rules the land. It’s up to you to prove if you are capable of ruling–and most importantly that you are better at it than other players!

Features & Use

Section rating:

Test device: LG Optimus Speed / 2x
Android version: 2.3.5
Mods: MIUI


Carcassonne was adapted for Android from a parlour or board game; you can imagine that transforming that kind of game so that it can be played on a tiny smartphone screen is quite a challenge.
The game has two game modes. Let’s take a look at the ‘Basic’ mode first.
The game can be played in horizontal or vertical screen mode. A tutorial in which everything is explained is available for first-time players. I’ve listed the most important rules for you:

You play with others (real players or AI) and you lay out tiles alternately.
Place followers on your tiles in order to gain points.
Every player starts off with seven followers.
Once you’ve placed a follower on a tile you will only get him back when the street, convent or city has been completed.
Whoever has the highest number of followers on a street, convent or city is the rightful owner.
Convents are completed when they are surrounded by landscape tiles.
The area that can be used for laying out tiles expands with every new round.

I recommend watching the tutorial twice just to drill these rules into your brain. Once you feel you’ve understood the gameplay you can go ahead and start playing a round.
The great thing is that you can play against friends as well as AI (change the settings from ‘Computer’ to ‘Person’ in order to do so).
It isn’t possible to change the level of difficulty when playing against a computer, which is unfortunate as this might make things a bit too challenging for new players. (Please not that I read in a few of the Market comments that other players were finding the AI opponents to be ‘stupid’, i.e. not challengin enough.)

The player who begins is selected at random every time you start a new game. Once that’s done every player gets a turn to lay down their tiles. The goal is to claim as many streets, convents and cities as your own.

It is imperative that you don’t lay out all of your followers–if you do it can become an issue when it comes to completing one of your constructions, because you won’t get any of your followers back, which in turn would mean that you can’t collect any more points.

So what does ‘completing’ something mean? Well, it’s different for every map. A city is completed when it is surrounded by a city wall; a street is completed when it leads towards some sort of structure, building, etc.; a convent is completed when it is surrounded by green tiles.

And that’s about all there is to say about this mode. Truth be told, I found this mode to be challenging when I first started playing, but I got the swing of things fairly quickly.

The second game mode is called ‘The River II’. The rules or generally the same as when playing the basic mode, the difference being that you have to lay out river maps as well as the normal one.

Let me say right off the bat that the tutorial for this mode is rather disappointing. My main issue is that it would seem that followers can be played on the river tiles, but I don’t quite get why, and the tutorial doesn’t provide any explanation.

Another thing I found puzzling: sometimes some free spaces will kind of break, making it impossible to lay out any maps/tiles. I’m a Carcassonne newbie and have to admit that I have no idea why this happens. Perhaps some of you old-stagers out there know what’s going on...? If so, let us know in the comments below or in the forum.

There are also 12 accomplishments as well as a few settings options such as setting the music volume and the speed of the animations. The music is really nice and totally helps set the mood.

Bottom line:
Carcassonne is an interesting game and it has been adapted for smartphone in a, well, smart way. If you’re a newbie like me you may also experience some initial confusion as the tutorial/instructions are somewhat below par. That being said, old hands shouldn’t have any trouble with the game.

Screen & Controls

Section rating:

The controls are quite simple–once you’ve understood the gameplay, that is. The controls elements are located near the bottom of the display, an indication that the app was originally designed for older Java phones.

The Carcassonne graphics are reminiscent of an old fashioned board game, and seeing how a lot of users will be used to flashy designs this might feel somewhat boring. The game on the whole feels a bit anachronistic.

Speed & Stability

Section rating:

I tested Carcassonne on a high end smartphone but despite this I experienced some bumpiness in the menu. The game itself runs smoothly, though. The loading times are totally digestible and there wasn’t any lagging or crashing.

Price/Performance Ratio

Section rating:

Carcassonne can be downloaded for EUR3,99 // US$5,46, and because it’s our app of the week it’s on special offer for only EUR1,99 // US$2,72 which is a pretty sweet deal for a pretty great game.

Comparable Apps

Catan

Report comparable or similar apps

Developer

exozet games de

Germany

exozet games - Game Development Studio.

Top App:

Catan
Catan 3.0: “Cities and Knights” expansion (IAP) now available, numerous optimizations to (...)
You must be logged in in order to become a fan of exozet games.
Good
Features
Screen
Speed
Price
Market Rating:
AndroidPIT User Rating:
Own Rating:
Log yourself in!
Copy badge
Ad

Bookmark / E-Mail

Click on an icon to bookmark this test report.
» Send this article via e-mail

Screenshots

Screenshot
Screenshot
Screenshot

All Test Reports

  • H. Moser Sep 21, 2011 Link

    Hi!

    According to your question:
    "Another thing I found puzzling: sometimes some free spaces will kind of break, making it impossible to lay out any maps/tiles. I’m a Carcassonne newbie and have to admit that I have no idea why this happens. Perhaps some of you old-stagers out there know what’s going on...? If so, let us know in the comments below or in the forum."

    i have the following answer for you:

    The free spaces sometimes break, because there is no more tile left in the staple that fill fit in this place - it's a strategic operation in Carcassonne when playing agaist each other (e.g. for not letting another player into "your" field or preventing him to finish a city) (the game is using the original tiles from the board game).

    Hopefully Exozet will deliver other Expansions of Carcassonne soon...

  • fdsia ofoda Sep 20, 2011 Link

    welcome to: http://www.plzzshop.com

    The website wholesale for many kinds of fashion shoes, like the nike,jordan,prada,****, also including the jeans,shirts,bags,hat and the decorations. All the products are free shipping, and the the price is competitive, and also can accept the paypal payment.,after the payment, can ship within short time.


    free shipping

    competitive price

    any size available

    accept the paypal

    http://www.plzzshop.com

Market Comments

A Google User, Jun 16, 2013
No multiplayer. Like, that's the whole point. Seriously, the whole point. Update : The fact that this game STILL doesn't have online multiplayer, regardless of numerous requests by consumers shows you how dedicated the programmer is. Do not download.
A Google User, Jun 16, 2013
Great Great! Must have for all game board geek
A Google User, Jun 9, 2013
Online Game Play If I could play actual people this game would be better.
A Google User, Jun 8, 2013
Classic! Simple but addictive and challenging. Love this game. If you like Settlers of Catan you will enjoy this.
A Google User, Jun 8, 2013
Great game I would like for the other expansions to be released. Ai could be a little better as well
A Google User, Jun 7, 2013
Add Online Multiplayer! A good game that could be great. Please add online multiplayer!
A Google User, Jun 4, 2013
Loved this game until all of my achievements were taken away. Why would a company do that?
A Google User, Jun 2, 2013
Good, room for improvement. It works to get my Carcassonne fix, but the animations and particularly the AI opponents are rather childish. Also, I bought it under the impression that local multiplayer meant Bluetooth or Wifi, not passing the tablet between players. My mistake, but I hope someone reading this avoids making the same error.
A Google User, May 31, 2013
I miss my battery.
A Google User, May 31, 2013
Needs multiplayer Otherwise, this is great!!
A Google User, May 31, 2013
Multiplayer: set standards higher The iPhone version lets one play over the internet against family or friends. Is that really too much to expect from a turn based, paid board game? 'Local multiplayer' according to exozet, means your friends take turns holding the phone.
A Google User, May 29, 2013
Great game! Definitely one of my favorite board games. This app pays good homage. I'm hoping that future releases will allow for online play and even some day far far in the future allow for cross platform (iOS) competition.
A Google User, May 29, 2013
Not bad but I have noticed several times now that it will not let me place tiles and people in places that I should be able to, very frustrating, also massive power drain from this app
A Google User, May 26, 2013
A battery hog... This is a great game but with limited AI, it's just not as good as playing humans if you're a serious player (winning all the time gets a bit boring). Worse still, it really drains the battery of my Galaxy S3 far quicker than any other app I own, meaning I am loath to play. If you're new to the game, it would be a great introduction and to hone strategies inbetween games with friends.
A Google User, May 23, 2013
Upgraded and I lost it.... Galaxy note can't reinstall game.. Updated: flaw was fixed. Fun game.
A Google User, May 22, 2013
Not Up To Par With iPhone Version I must say that one of the biggest reasons it took me so long to migrate from an iPhone user to and Android user is that the Carcassonne app for iPhone, made by TheCodingMonkeys, is so excellent. It enables users to play against other users all over the world and incorporates a ranking system much like chess. These are features which should be present here. Additionally, the graphical user interface of that app is outstanding and makes this app seem amateur in may aesthetic ways as well. Perhaps Android users do not realize how much better that Carcassonne app is, or perhaps we're all just willing to make the sacrifice for other benefits which Android provides, but there really is no comparison between these apps. I would love to give this app a 5 star rating, because this is my favorite board game of all time. However, having used such a better version in the iPhone previously, the shortcomings of this app are undeniable and really exemplify how much improvement could be made here. I hope that Exozet games is working on some improvements as I would be willing to pay another $5 for the ability to play against live opponents, and $3-5 for expansion packs.
A Google User, May 21, 2013
Update compatibility Had update compatibility issues with release 7, but the developer stepped in quickly to resolve them. Graphics don't look that great on the Note 10.1 when zoomed out - like it is not properly optimised for the device resolution, but gameplay is fine.
A Google User, May 21, 2013
I serious play everyday. Really I love this game. Sadly, really really sadly, all of my achievements disappeared after the most recent update!
A Google User, May 20, 2013
Good but could be so much better Good conversion of the fantastic board game. But long term playability against computer opponents could be improved. Recent updates made viewing my Nexus 4 much better. However it would be so much better it there were more of the expansion packs included and if there were more objective badges (& perhaps more levels to the existing ones). Perhaps the expansion packs could be earnt through achievements?
A Google User, May 20, 2013
Excellent, but more expansions please! Excellent game, and the AI is pretty decent! Wouldnt mind if there existed some more of the expansions for it. I can see myself paying up to a dollar for the bigger ones.
Go to pg.: 1 2 3 ... 22 »