Sign in

Sign in to confirm

Have you forgotten your password?

... or login with Facebook:

Don't have an AndroidPIT account yet? Sign up

Watch Out, Nokia – You May Be Infringing a Dead Dutch Painter!*

Steven Blum
8

The new Windows 8 interface that Nokia just debuted on their Lumia 920 is beautiful, no doubt, but it's not necessarily original. In fact, it almost looks as if Microsoft lifted the UI right from the canvas of a Mondrian painting. Just look at the Windows' similarity to paintings by the famous (and long dead) Dutch painter Pieter Cornelis Mondrian:

According to Wikipedia, Mondrian developed his grid-like abstract painting style in the 1930's. While they weren't patented, they were created prior (faaaar prior) to the Windows 8 phone. Prior art, people!

Given the absurdity of present-day patent law, might we see Mondrain's estate suing Windows?*

* We're joking, of course, but it's a funny thing to think about.

(Hat tip: Stephen Levy on Twitter)

Comments

Write new comment:
  • Tom Harder Sep 5, 2012 Link

    Why not? And in the same sense the Roddenberry estate and Paramount Pictures should be suing Apple. Star Trek introduced us to a tablet device long before Apple ever did. Watch an episode of The Next Generation. They frequently use a device called a PADD (Peronal Access Data Device). It is a thin recrangular touch screen device with rounded corners and icons approximately the same dimensions as most of today's 10" tablets..... Apples innovative ideas my asteroid.....

    0
  • John A Sep 6, 2012 Link

    off topic but here is a blast from the past :) Now that was a tablet.

    www.youtube.com/watch?v=ahnVRr1Sa0E

    I wonder who owns all the Atari patents

    0
  • John A Sep 6, 2012 Link

    sorry guys, new nexus 7 sent this a few times.

    0
  • John A Sep 6, 2012 Link

    sorry guys, new nexus 7 sent this a few times.

    0
  • Stan Jez Sep 6, 2012 Link

    No problems John. I'm sure we've all done it. I hope you're enjoying your nexus 7 as much as I am.

    0
  • Patrick R. Sep 6, 2012 Link

    Haha Steven, and I thought I came up with the design for that with paint, on windows 3.1 in the 90s (didn't we all do this?).

    0
  • Patrick R. Sep 6, 2012 Link

    Just got back from your video link john. Believe it or not, Atari still exists. I think it was bought by the same people who bought Microprose (Civilization, Sword of the Samurai etc.) and they rebranded themselves as Atari.

    0
  • Steven Blum Sep 6, 2012 Link

    LOL, Patrick. Well then clearly you should sue, too. Let's all sue!

    John A, thank you for reminding me about Atari!

    0