This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. OK

Smartwatches are very exciting, but like any new technology early adopters are likely to spend a lot on devices that won't stand the test of - yes! - time.

gwatch r 2
This photo shows all the nice looking smartwatches that exist. ALL OF THEM / © LG

A few days ago, Kris asked an important question: how much is too much for a smartwatch

I know the answer. Unless you’ve got lots of spare money and don’t mind backing the wrong horse, any amount of money is too much for a smartwatch. Smartwatches are going to be brilliant, but they aren’t brilliant yet. 

Come with me. I’ve got a time machine.

*whooshing noise*

It’s 2008 and Google has made a phone. In the US it’s called the Dream. In the rest of the world it’s the T-Mobile G1. And it’s rubbish.

Don’t get me wrong. As a hint of where Android would end up, it was really interesting. But as a phone it wasn’t that good. The screen wasn’t multitouch and there was no virtual keyboard. There were hardly any apps. You needed a special adapter to use headphones. It was heavy, the screen wasn’t very good and the music app didn’t sound very nice. Engadget said it was “reasonable”. Every review said the same thing: it was good, but the iPhone was better.

**whooshing noise*

T Mobile G1
T-Mobile's G1 was good, but not great. / © (c) Wikipedia

Look at the current crop of smartwatches. Getting deja vu yet? I am.

I’m convinced that smartwatches will be fantastic, but I’m equally convinced that buying one just now is a bad idea. This is a category so new that the manufacturers can’t even decide which operating system is best. Is it Tuesday? Samsung’s on Android Wear. Thursday? Tizen.

It’s not just the OS. Most smartwatches are ugly - Samsung’s Gear S hasn’t so much been hit with the ugly stick as thrown into the ugly sleeping bag, rolled in the ugly tent and thrown into the ugly canal - and the Moto 360 looks like somebody strapped a plate to your arm. For my money there’s only one genuinely good looking smartwatch so far, and that’s the LG G Watch R - but that might not be as pretty in the plastic as it looks in the renders.

The only watch I would consider getting is the LG G Watch R. / © LG

There are other issues too. There’s price. There’s battery life and charging. There’s the issue of sensors and who can access the data they create. There’s the fact that nobody seems entirely sure what smartwatches are supposed to do. 

And more than anything, there’s Apple’s imminent iThing. Love Apple or hate it, if its take on wearables does an iPhone and makes an entire industry smack its head and go “aha! That’s how you do it!” then everybody’s going to copy it - so you might as well wait until they do and get an Android-flavored version of it. 

This year’s smartwatches are the T-Mobile G1s. Wouldn’t you rather wait for their equivalent of the Galaxy S5?


Write new comment:
  • More interested when they can strap one to the prop of an outboard, and show 'IT'S STILL TICKING'. Fragile electronic on my wrist = dead electronics. The round LG watch looks promising!

  • Ha ha, excellent article Gary and very true. I think we forget these things in our eagerness and excitement to early adopt sometimes. I know I do! The speed with which technology moves forward these days, we will probably be laughing out loud at this first crop of smart watches, in a couple of years when the tech has moved forward.

  • flooney Sep 3, 2014 Link to comment

    We'll see what happen. It's done when it's done ^^

  • My1 Sep 2, 2014 Link to comment

    no. Note 3 equiv is enough and S5 too small... :-P

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. More info

Got it!