This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. OK
155 Shares 10 comments

Samsung's dilemma: to bring the Galaxy S8 forward or not?

Through the Galaxy Note 7, Samsung has brought some trouble into the house. The overly ambitious product plan has had some disastrous consequences. Samsung could bring forward the release of the Galaxy S8 however, this would actually only have a marginal effect.

Samsung had reportedly imposed an ambitious schedule on developers of the Note 7 in order to release the Note 7 on the market ahead of the iPhone 7. The logic behind this was: early sales of the Note 7 ahead of a marginally improved iPhone 7. Of course, all signs pointed to record sales. But it seems rather unlikely that this approach was what led to the Note 7 recall. Samsung did not comment on these reports but the rumor has gone viral.

The next high-end smartphone from Samsung will be the Galaxy S8 and Samsung is hanging its hopes on it. But the battery problems have produced some serious image damage to Samsung.

From a financial point of view, Samsung could jump on the idea of bringing the Galaxy S8 to the marketplace earlier than anticipated – analysts are expecting this move. But when should Samsung do it? Traditionally, Samsung presents its new Galaxy S smartphones each year at the Mobile World Congress (MWC) in Barcelona. More important to know is when sales would start. In 2016, this happened around mid-March. This year, Samsung had a special advantage: there were no alternatives among the competition – neither HTC, Lenovo / Motorola, LG nor Sony had any big new offerings up their sleeves – so if anyone wanted a high-end catch shortly after MWC, their only option was the Galaxy S7. This undoubtedly gave Samsung an enormous advantage.

But back to the question: when? Samsung would have to once again win some sort of timely advantage with the Galaxy S8. This year, the situation is different: against the background of Note 7 rumors, an early presentation of the S8 would, of course, be critically assessed. A good opportunity would certainly be the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in Las Vegas in January: the first big tech event would be suitable as a launching stage. But everything points against Samsung daring to take this route: although Samsung would probably polish off the figures of the first (calendar) quarter of 2017, the move would probably not have a long-term advantage for the company. Ultimately, February is just not the time for hardware purchases.

There is only one scenario in which Samsung could undo the Note 7 debacle while simultaneously driving the company's sales figures up: Samsung would have to get the Galaxy S8 into stores for the Christmas shopping season. However, even this approach entails considerable risks: to compress the development schedule by several months could result in the Galaxy S8's appearance as an unfinished product. Samsung cannot risk this. Even then, Samsung would also probably have to fight the impression that the Galaxy S8 would have come to the market as a panic product.

Hans-Georg Kluge
Samsung will present the Galaxy S8 shortly before the MWC.
What do you think?
I agree
I disagree

Upon closer inspection, there is actually no sensible reason for Samsung to push for an early release of the Galaxy S8. That is why they should stay the course: let the MWC be the launch of the new generation Galaxy.

It remains to be seen whether Samsung can rescue the image of the Note 7. Maybe a reboot would help? J.J. Abrams could be responsible for this. As for Samsung's Christmas business, that may also end up being scarce.

What do you think? Can Samsung save itself from the Note 7? Or will Samsung play a risky game and bring the S8 out early? Let us know your thoughts in the comments!


Write new comment:
  • rick 2 days ago Link to comment

    please dont rush the s8!!! I want to get this device, and I dont want to feel ripped off. I own the s7, and Im very happy with this device. Im looking forward to a beautiful upgrade, the s8 should be that device. I owned all Samsung s series, and two LG devices , I like the Samsung s series. I hope both variants of the s8 pack the same camera, and screens, and storage. Hopefully the get great batteries too. Ill be watching for s8 leaks, and onfo on the specs. Come on Samsung, make a great come back, make the s8 a beast!!!

  • Coffee 5 days ago Link to comment

    It may have over simplified the whole mystery saying the problem of Note7 a consequence of an ambitious R&D programme. If you have really used it you know how refined a product it is. From product design to software, implementation of features, not a glitch you will complain about, it simply not something made in rush. I don't see giving them a few more months may make any different. The problem happened in a rate rarer than 1 out of 10000. You really think the QA procedure will be able to spot and fix it before putting into production? I just don't think so.

    • Bastian Siewers
      • Admin
      • Staff
      5 days ago Link to comment


      it really depends on what actually caused the problem after all, and until now, its simply speculation. Yes, the Galaxy Note 7 was/is a refined smartphone, that's true. But so far, it looks like they did take it a step to far in terms of a "huge" battery in a considerably thin smartphone.

  • They can not take the risk of releasing an unfinished product. Maybe they can provide some upgrade to s7 line in the form of storage, colour options etc to attract the Xmas shoppers and better take time for proper testing before releasing the next flagship

  • I hope Samsung play safe..
    if they bring forward S8 and it has battery problems.?!.
    that really would be a major disaster..
    basically they produced a faulty device, then offered an equally faulty replacement..
    another major fault would cost Sammy its no1 spot, and take years to recover from.

  • Not having another Premium phone for sale over xmas will hit Samsung bad, not releasing the S7 edge plus was a wrong decision by Samsung, Samsung X might be the phone they will show off in Barcelona, but the Note 7 saga will put people off buying the S8 phones

  • Mark 1 week ago Link to comment

    I just hope Samsung learns from it's mistakes, doesn't rush another product that is not ready. Give us two variants your all glass edge for those who want a sealed battery, and a regular model with a removable back and replaceable battery. Samsung- quit forgetting about your original customer base who you abandoned to go after Apple. Look where it has gotten you less and less market share. Go back to your roots your, customers will follow.

  • storm 1 week ago Link to comment

    Let the S7 be the phone for now. RUshing to beat Apple was part of the Note 7 problem most likely. Better to wait and do it right and keep the schedules.

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. More info

Got it!